My Daughter, My Secret

I never thought being overweight would be the biggest blessing in my life.
I never thought I’d be able to pull this off.
I never thought I’d be telling my story.

But all I can hope is that my baby darling will read this someday.

I conceived a child with a former friend of mine who, as of publishing, has never acknowledged that he is the father of a human being on earth. We aren’t and weren’t married, but were fooling around, having fun. Fun has consequences. I tried letting him know to give him the opportunity to know, to meet the child during the two weeks I got to know her, but nary a call got answered or a text read.

When I discovered I was carrying a child, I froze. My whole life fell apart.I am a relatively public individual in the frum community I lived in, a place I want to stay. I’m also single, with hopes to marry.

For the first three months, I cried and prayed I would miscarry.
For the next three months, I confided and planned with the people closest to me.
For the last three months, I cried and hid.

For three weeks, I dreaded the day.
For two days, I labored alone in a hospital.
For two weeks, I hid in a friend’s apartment with a baby.
And for eight months, I’ve wondered.

Where she lives, what she’s like, what she’ll think of me, if I’ll ever cross paths with her and if I made the right decision.

But no one else in my community even noticed. Outside of the comments “Wow, You’ve lost so much weight!!” or the occasional “Where were you over the summer?” No one’s been the wiser, but me? Now I’m a momma, but I don’t have a daughter.

I opted for a closed adoption with placement in a frum home, I’m told she is happy, she is settling, and is a very sweet baby girl.

But inside, I wonder, if I wouldn’t be ostracized from my community, if I knew my child would have a school to go to, if I knew I would have a job as a single and never married mother, would I have been brave enough to keep her?

What if I had heeded the advice of some and moved to Israel where no one had to know, could I have kept her?

What if I would have heeded the other advice I got and gotten rid of her? Would I be able to live with myself more? Would I feel like my Shidduch prospects would be less limiting?

Of course, I plan to share with my future husband the ghost I hold in my closet, but how many ghosts can a human being handle?

At nights, I cry myself to sleep and wish I was still pregnant, with her close to me, inside me, my secret.

By day, I numbly walk through the streets, observe the mothers with their carriages and the children running with their siblings. I bite my lip and wait till I get home to cry.

Because I’m a Momma, who hasn’t been allowed her daughter.

(Visited 4,979 times, 1 visits today)


  1. Laura E. October 31, 2017 at 3:56 pm

    Bless you. I’m so sorry for your grief.

  2. Healing October 31, 2017 at 4:54 pm

    This breaks my heart. I’m so sorry. I wish you so much to find peace.

  3. Anonymous October 31, 2017 at 5:38 pm

    I’m so sorry to hear of your pain. I pray Hashem helps you find comfort and strength during this time and that you find the silver lining in this, wherever it may be.

  4. chana October 31, 2017 at 6:40 pm

    I think your actions show your daughter how much you love her.
    You gave her 2 loving parents. And a place in society.

    May you be comforted from your sorrow.

  5. Lis Shapiro October 31, 2017 at 10:02 pm

    May you derive strength from your courageous decisions, to bring a life into the world, and to love your baby so much that you provide pd her a future.
    May your nights and days be blessed, and you continue despite the pain, to love again and be loved, and build a bayit ne’eman.

  6. Vered November 1, 2017 at 3:45 am

    I just want to give you a bug hug! You are very brave.
    Love from The Holy Land

  7. Lea November 1, 2017 at 9:59 am

    You are so beautiful and courageous inside and out!! You gave your daughter the most awesome gift of all, the gift of life!!! You carried her for 9 months within your womb, you gave birth to her and made sure she’s in a loving home. I wish you that knowing this will bring you peace of mind and that one day you meet with her. Who knows…perhaps one day you will become great friends?

  8. Anonymous November 1, 2017 at 12:22 pm

    My heart breaks for you as a new mother myself. It;s not fair! I hope that one day soon you can bring your daughter back to you.

  9. Seraphim November 1, 2017 at 9:11 pm

    I am so, so sorry for your pain, and the loss and emptiness you must feel. What an incredibly selfless act you have made for your daughter. I am also sorry that you felt that your community limited you in the choices that you were able to make. Hopefully this will change over time, and that being a single mother will not be viewed with such derision in the future.

  10. Anonymous January 31, 2018 at 12:30 am

    I am heartbroken and angered to read this! So sorry that you were faced with that choice. Sometimes I wonder if we live our lives for ourselves or for those around us? Which perspective would give us true pleasure in life? And most of all, what would God want for us?

  11. Supporter December 5, 2018 at 4:08 pm

    I’m so sorry ! Maybe u can find peace in knowing that u may Have given an infertile couple the greatest gift . For the record , I fully support the idea of older siblings having children . Just because u dont have a husband – that doesn’t mean u shouldn’t have a child

  12. Chaya charna July 12, 2019 at 5:57 pm

    Wow , my heart breaks for you. You are incredibly brave to put your story out there. The tears I cried reading this I imagine are nothing compared to the ones you shed day in and day out. I dont know you but if you ever feel the need to cry on a friends shoulder I’m here. Even though I’m random I’m here. I have been through extremely tough times although not this particular event. But something close. Sending love , courage to grow accept yourself and the situation for its entirety <3


Note: ONLY sensitive comments will be approved.